FCC lets Peshawar High Court hear Article 199 petitions AI-generated image

FCC lets Peshawar High Court hear Article 199 petitions

Newsora24 staff
5 minRead
0Views
0Reading now

The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) on Monday changed its November 5 restraining order, allowing the Peshawar High Court (PHC) to hear constitutional petitions under Article 199. The court said the earlier restrictions applied only to matters linked to governor’s rule and to detentions under the Maintenance of Public Order (MPO) Ordinance in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP).

A two-member bench headed by Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan, with Justice Aamer Farooq, issued the clarification while hearing a case about the high court’s constitutional jurisdiction. That jurisdiction was in question after emergency and governor’s rule were imposed in KP.

How Article 199 applies to the emergency and detention cases

Article 199 of the Constitution gives high courts the power to exercise constitutional jurisdiction. This includes reviewing actions taken by public authorities, enforcing fundamental rights and checking whether a person’s detention is lawful. It also lets individuals seek judicial relief against government decisions, which makes it central to petitions challenging governor’s rule, emergency measures and MPO detentions.

During the hearing, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) Chairman Barrister Gohar Ali Khan told the court that the November 5 order had disrupted work at the PHC. According to him, the order had affected constitutional petitions and the professional practice of lawyers. The bench responded that the restraining order was meant to cover only governor’s rule and MPO matters, and that the high court could keep hearing other Article 199 petitions.

Justice Farooq also addressed Article 245, which deals with the deployment of armed forces in aid of civil power. He observed that a plain reading of the article could suggest limits on the high court’s constitutional jurisdiction. He warned, however, that applying such an interpretation broadly would effectively paralyse the judicial system.

FCC lets Peshawar High Court hear Article 199 petitions
AI-generated illustration

Gohar presses for relief for detained PTI workers

Barrister Gohar asked the court to grant relief to people held under Section 3 of the MPO Ordinance. He said several PTI workers and leaders remained in custody without effective access to judicial remedies. He told the bench that KP had not yet set up a review board for preventive detention cases, and he asked that applications concerning detained persons be decided quickly.

Gohar also raised concerns about detainees held at Police Lines and urged the judges to consider measures that would let them seek relief. The KP advocate general told the court that a review board would be formed after three months. He added that any detention extending beyond that period could be referred to the board for consideration.

Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan said several miscellaneous applications had been filed at the Peshawar registry and would be examined once they reached the bench. He added that, apart from the bar council’s application, the other petitions had not yet been fixed for hearing. The court allowed the bar council to become a party to the proceedings.

Justice Farooq described the emergency-related litigation as an important constitutional matter. He stressed that bar councils should take part in the proceedings. The bench then adjourned the case for an indefinite period.

After the hearing, Gohar said he had asked the FCC to let the PHC resume proceedings on petitions challenging emergency and governor’s rule. These petitions also sought the recovery of detained political leaders. In a post on X, the PTI chairman said the November 5 order had affected petitions concerning the provincial chief minister, the assembly speaker and other parliamentarians.

He maintained that the PHC should decide whether those petitions were maintainable and whether the court had jurisdiction to hear them. Gohar further argued that denying MPO detainees access to bail and judicial hearings violated their fundamental rights. His remarks set out the relief PTI is seeking, while the FCC’s clarification addressed only the scope of its earlier order.

November 5 order and the emergency measures in KP

The dispute goes back to the FCC’s November 5 ruling, which restricted the PHC’s constitutional jurisdiction. That ruling came during hearings on petitions filed by the KP government against high court orders on the detention and release of political workers. The court had restrained proceedings on Article 199 petitions filed on or after October 12, citing the deployment of armed forces in aid of civil power under Article 245.

After that ruling, the PHC’s administrative committee stopped scheduling the affected constitutional petitions. It also directed that fresh applications be returned to the petitioners. The restrictions hit several politically sensitive cases, including challenges to emergency and governor’s rule and requests to recover detained PTI leaders. Lawyers objected, and bar associations questioned what the ruling meant for access to justice and for the high court’s constitutional authority.

The emergency and governor’s rule were imposed in KP on October 11, after President Asif Ali Zardari approved recommendations from the federal government. Those steps came amid political tensions and concerns about the security situation. Under the measures, the provincial administration came under federal control. Governor Faisal Karim Kundi assumed executive authority, and the PTI-led provincial government became non-functional.

The federal government then authorised army personnel to assist the civil administration in maintaining law and order under Article 245. PTI challenged the measures before the PHC and sought the restoration of the elected provincial government. Gohar had filed a petition on October 14 questioning the constitutional validity of the emergency and governor’s rule. The PHC later reserved its decision on these petitions, before the FCC’s November 5 order halted proceedings.

Monday’s clarification allows the PHC to hear other Article 199 petitions. The wider legal questions about emergency powers, governor’s rule and preventive detention, however, remain unresolved.

Leave an opinion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Story saved