Rana Sanaullah, the adviser to the prime minister on political affairs, has asked President Asif Ali Zardari to talk to his “sons”, Bilawal Bhutto Zardari and Mohsin Naqvi, and encourage them to keep the debate on new provinces constructive. Speaking on the programme Jirga, Sanaullah said the president should contact both men and explain that each is free to back or reject the creation of new provinces, but that the discussion must stay healthy.
The exchange comes as the debate over new provinces has sharpened. On Wednesday night, the Pakistan Peoples Party chairman criticised the federal government, saying he expected opposition from politicians who, in his view, lacked the courage to hear the truth.
Sanaullah’s remarks on Zardari and Naqvi
The programme’s anchor summarised Sanaullah’s position by saying that one of the “sons” supports new provinces while the other opposes them. The anchor added that President Zardari publicly refers to Naqvi as his son. Sanaullah, who is a PML-N leader, said the debate should not be allowed to become polluted and that those in favour should be free to make their case while opponents should also be heard.
Also read: Planning minister says 14-province plan under discussion
Sanaullah also questioned how the issue could have gone undiscussed between the president and the interior minister, whom he said meets the president often. He described Naqvi as a senator supported by both the Pakistan Peoples Party and the PML-N, and said Naqvi was frequently seen at the President’s House and had met Zardari in London, Australia and Nawabshah.

Bilawal’s warning and the ministers’ response
Bilawal responded to a series of statements from federal ministers earlier on the same day. He said the ministers had apparently decided to confront him for speaking the truth, adding that their reaction showed they were unwilling to tolerate criticism. He also asked how ordinary citizens could expect their voices to reach the government if politicians refused to listen to him.
Federal ministers had strongly opposed Bilawal’s objection to the proposed division of Sindh. They argued that smaller provinces were needed for better governance and that public opinion should decide the matter. Defence Minister Khawaja Asif stressed that no political system could be changed without public backing, while Federal Minister for Health Mustafa Kamal described smaller provinces as inevitable. Talal Chaudhry also questioned Bilawal’s stance, pointing to the party’s position on the division of Punjab and arguing that democracy required effective governance rather than speeches and constitutional arguments.
Earlier, on Tuesday, Bilawal had warned that if Sindh were divided by force, questions would be raised about the blood spilled on the streets of Karachi and Hyderabad.
Bilawal calls for an open debate
Bilawal said he was offering suggestions as a major stakeholder and urged political leaders to act with caution. He complained that the discussion on new provinces had started without consulting any minister, the prime minister or other political stakeholders. “If you have initiated this debate, have the courage to hold it openly. It cannot be conducted through your own selected people, with everyone else expected to agree or remain silent,” he said.
The PPP chairman also argued that the discussion should address the country’s fundamental problems rather than focus only on new provinces. He questioned who had the authority to declare that the system had collapsed and to decide that it needed to be reset. “Does the PCB chairman have the authority to say that the system has collapsed? Has the responsibility for deciding on a reset been handed to the PCB?” he asked.
Bilawal sought to clarify his earlier warning. “I was sounding the alarm, not issuing a threat. I was warning about the consequences if such a move was forced through,” he said, adding that coercion could trigger unrest that would be difficult to contain.