Bilawal Bhutto questions Naqvi’s role in governance reset AI-generated image

Bilawal Bhutto questions Naqvi’s role in governance reset

Newsora24 staff
5 minRead
0Views
0Reading now

Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari has said he has every right to take part in the debate over a proposed political reset, arguing that as a stakeholder in the country’s governance system he should be free to question how it is changed. Speaking in an interview with HUM News programme “Faisala Aap Ka”, hosted by Asma Shirazi, he said the discussion could not leave out him or other political stakeholders. The interview was his first with a Pakistani television channel since a press conference he held in Karachi on Tuesday.

Bilawal said the reaction to his earlier remarks showed that his critics had also chosen to confront him, and were showing little interest in hearing unwelcome views. “I spoke a little too much truth yesterday, and they are finding it difficult to digest,” he said. He asked whether a system that had supposedly collapsed could be fixed through a political or non-political reset, and whether the reform should be seen as a matter of who had caused the problem in the first place.

Bilawal challenges who is steering the reset

Bilawal said neither he nor President Asif Ali Zardari had been consulted about the proposed changes. He questioned whether Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi or the chairman of the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) had been empowered to decide how the governance system should be reset. His remarks were a direct response to Naqvi’s claim that the existing system had failed and needed to be rebuilt.

Bilawal also rejected the idea that the system had collapsed on its own. He said it had instead been deliberately brought down, an apparent rebuttal of the interior minister’s position. Those comments set the tone for a wider dispute over how far political parties should have a say in reform.

Bilawal Bhutto questions Naqvi's role in governance reset
AI-generated illustration

PPP opposes referendum and warns over Sindh

At the Karachi press conference, Bilawal criticised proposals to create new provinces through a referendum and cautioned against any move to divide Sindh without the consent of its people. Referring to Naqvi’s suggestion of a referendum on new administrative units, he said that in Pakistan’s history such votes had been used for undemocratic purposes rather than democratic ones.

He warned that any attempt to split Sindh by force would spark serious unrest. Bilawal said he was sounding a warning rather than making a threat, and pointed to the province’s political turmoil in the 1980s and 1990s. “If something is imposed by force, there will be such a fire in this province that it will be difficult to put out,” he said, adding that bloodshed would further harm the country’s already strained economy.

Bilawal argued that the Constitution already provides a mechanism for creating new provinces. He questioned why public money should be spent on what he called a “fake referendum”.

Views on Fazlur Rehman, the 27th Amendment and the coalition

In the HUM News interview, Bilawal said political criticism should not be treated as hostility. Referring to criticism from Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam-Fazl chief Maulana Fazlur Rehman, he asked whether political disagreement should lead to punitive action. He also called the creation of the Federal Constitutional Court under the 27th Amendment a historic achievement, and said he was not seeking to reverse the amendment or abolish the constitutional courts.

On the opposition’s demands, Bilawal said he could not accept the claim that every prime minister of Pakistan had been corrupt. He said he hoped to see a prime minister complete a term without ending up in jail, and described Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf founder Imran Khan as both a politician and a prisoner.

Bilawal defended the PPP’s place in the governing coalition. He said the party was backing Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif in the national interest, even though it had little appetite for sitting on the government benches. “I still want Shehbaz Sharif to succeed,” he said, adding that supporting the government carried political costs for his party.

Government figures push back on Bilawal’s remarks

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif responded on social media platform X, saying that anyone demanding equity must first have “clean hands”. His comments came amid visible differences between coalition partners PML-N and PPP, and followed Naqvi’s remarks about the governance system and his idea of new administrative units, including through a referendum.

Information Minister Attaullah Tarar also addressed Bilawal’s warning about Sindh, reminding him that the PPP and PML-N sit together in the same coalition government. “We are part of the same government. Come and sit down so we can make decisions for the betterment of the people and the country,” Tarar said. He argued that parties which had been part of the governing system for decades could not distance themselves from its shortcomings.

Defending the proposed referendum, Tarar said the public should be allowed to voice its views on new provinces. “The people are the ultimate decision-makers. If the people of Pakistan and Sindh want more provinces, then make them; otherwise, don’t,” he said.

The exchange has exposed a clear split within the coalition over administrative reform. Bilawal opposes a referendum and warns against imposing changes on Sindh, while government representatives have called for public consultation.

Leave an opinion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Story saved