Prominent religious scholars have lauded for issuing an unconditional apology following the broadcast of the “Safar-e-Ishq” documentary on the 10th of Muharram. They emphasized that the channel, embodying true Muslim values, made clear it did not intend to be associated with any content deemed improper or offensive.
In a video statement, Allama Kaukab Noorani Okarvi highlighted that while Muslims uphold freedom of expression, they practice restraint in thought. He stressed that any form of disrespect, insolence, or blasphemy is completely unacceptable to Muslims. The visual content aired on Geo Television was inappropriate and should never have been shown. Although such an incident was unforeseen in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, it occurred unintentionally.
Okarvi noted that promptly took notice, removed all related material, issued an apology, and published a full repentance. The channel clarified that, consistent with true Muslim principles, it rejects involvement in anything unlawful or offensive that might hurt religious sentiments. Furthermore, those responsible were dismissed and disciplinary measures were implemented. Strict safeguards and administrative protocols have been introduced to prevent recurrence. The scholar praised the clear and unconditional repentance published in newspapers, hoping Geo remains steadfast in its commitment to avoid similar mistakes. He also urged the Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (PEMRA) to monitor the media environment closely and act swiftly against any comparable violations.
Separately, Allama Ibtisam Elahi Zaheer, Chairman of the Quran-o-Sunnah Movement Pakistan, stated that any depiction of the Holy Prophet (PBUH) or other Prophets—whether with or without facial features—is unacceptable and prohibited, regardless of intent. However, he acknowledged that if a media outlet admits the error, apologizes unconditionally, disciplines those involved, and assures such lapses will not recur, it deserves an opportunity for reform. He emphasized the need for stronger editorial oversight and accountability within broadcasting institutions.
Mufti Muhammad Naveed Abbasi, head of Markaz Uloom-ul-Quran in Clifton, Karachi, reiterated that Sharia forbids any visual portrayal of the Holy Prophet (PBUH), other Prophets, the Companions, Mothers of the Believers, and Ahl-ul-Bayt. This prohibition stands even when intended as a sign of respect, as it conflicts with religious sensitivities and the sanctity of these figures. He pointed out that the documentary contained symbolic representations of the Prophet (PBUH) and his grandsons, which scholars unanimously consider strictly forbidden. Nonetheless, he commended for acknowledging the mistake, removing the content, and announcing corrective measures. He stated that Islamic ethics call for accepting apologies when sincere repentance and practical steps to amend errors are demonstrated.
Distinguished scholar Mufti Muhammad Hanif Qureshi also affirmed that such symbolic depictions violate religious law. He observed that took immediate responsibility, admitted the fault, and issued an apology. He regarded this as a positive step, noting that the channel’s owners have publicly acknowledged their administrative shortcomings and sought forgiveness from Allah through official advertisements.
